Article 229 of Indian Constitution: Officers and servants and expenses of High Courts

Article 229 of Indian Constitution manages the administration of High Court staff and its expenses. It gives power to the Chief Justice of the High Court to appoint staff, decide on working conditions, and maintain expenses like salaries and other benefits charges from the Consolidated Fund. This Article restricts the staff of the High Court during the service. They can not be appointed to other services in other authorities as per the state guidelines. It helps the judiciary stay independent and efficient while working. Explore other Constitutional Articles.

Article 229 of Indian Constitution

Officers and servants and the expenses of High Courts

1. Appointments of officers and servants of a High Court shall be made by the Chief Justice of the Court or such other Judge or officer of the Court as he may direct:

Provided that the Governor of the State may by rule require that in such cases as may be specified in the rule, no person not already attached to the Court shall be appointed to any office connected with the Court save after consultation with the State Public Service Commission.

2. Subject to the provisions of any law made by the Legislature of the State, the conditions of service of officers and servants of a High Court shall be such as may be prescribed by rules made by the Chief Justice of the Court or by some other Judge or officer of the Court authorised by the Chief Justice to make rules for the purpose:

Provided that the rules made under this clause shall, so far as they relate to salaries, allowances, leave, or pensions, require the approval of the Governor of the State.

3. The administrative expenses of a High Court, including all salaries, allowances and pensions payable to or in respect of the officers and servants of the court, shall be charged upon the Consolidated Fund of the State, and any fees or other moneys taken by the Court shall form part of that Fund.

Note: "The information above has been added from the official website, i.e., Indian Code. This content is for reference only, and no changes have been added to the provision of the Article." 

Article 229 of Indian Constitution under Part VI empowers the Chief Justice of High Court to manage the High Court administration and make rules for regulation for proper functioning. However, the Chief Justice requires consultation with the Governor of a particular state of High Court jurisdiction to make an appointment. Following this, the Chief Justice can transfer his responsibility to some other judge of the High Court for administrative work to maintain the continuation of Court functioning.

Authority of the Chief Justice

Article 229 gives power to the Chief Justice to administer the proper functioning of the High Court, which includes the following points:

• Appointment: Only the Chief Justice appoints staff and servants for their court, whether it's a High Court. This ensures the judicial fraternity, where the judiciary itself makes appointments for its court and does not allow external interference from the judiciary executive.
• The Chief Judge is to appoint the High Court officers and servants of the High Court. This ensures that the judiciary retains control of its staff without unnecessary interference from the executive.
• Delegation: The chief Judge may delegate these powers to another judge or official in the High Court and support the flexibility and effectiveness of administrative functions.

Consultation with the State Public Service Commission

Consultation is required with the state Public Service Commission because the Governor holds the power to make rules regarding the High Court appointment to eye on them in the following ways:

• It ensures transparency and standardization in recruitment.
• It prevents potential non -interference or protectionism in court staff appointments.

However, this Article is only concerned with the appointment connected with the High Court.

Conditions of Service

Article 229 of Indian Constitution implicates the conditions of service of the authority of the High Court from which the Chief Justice of a particular state manages proper functioning, including the following points:

• Salaries and contributions.
• Leave politicians.
• Pension benefits.

The requirement to approve the Governor regarding the rules on financial matters introduces the element of supervision and ensures that public funds are used deliberately. At the same time, it maintains balance by leaving non-financial aspects completely under the radiation of the main Judge.

Financial Provisions

Article 229 of Indian Constitution maintains the administrative functions include salaries of judges and staff of the High Court, which Consolidated Funds charge includes certain points:

• Shield High Courts before financial restrictions or delays imposed by an executive or legislator.
• It guarantees a safe and continuous flow of funds, allowing smooth functioning.
• This article makes the Higher Judicial body of the state financially independent and it is a part of the democratic system.

Article 229 of Indian Constitution signifies the importance of a properly functioning High Court, which helps the court's autonomy and integrity in the following manner:

1. Judicial Independence Control: This Article gives the High Court power to control the affairs of the administration. It also includes maintaining staff appointments and service while ensuring control over external interference.
2. Financial Independence: The High Court manages its expenses from the state Consolidated Fund. Article 229 ensures independence from the executive. 
3. Separation of Powers: It upholds the separation of powers by keeping High Courts separate from the legislature and executive.
4. Efficient Functioning of the High Court: Article 229 of Indian Constitution maintains the smooth operation of the High Court to enable judges to deliver justice.
5. Strengthening Judicial Integrity: Article 229 ensures that the High Court manages integrity by ensuring administrative credibility, which promotes public trust in its freedom

Article 229 of Indian Constitution Landmark Cases

Article 229 of Indian Constitution questions the Chief Justice's power of the high to maintain the administration functions related to the appointment of staff and make rules regarding services. Various case laws seek the importance of this Article:

1. State of Assam v. S.N.

The Supreme Court emphasized the importance of Article 229 in maintaining the independence of the judiciary. The Court ruled that:

• The main Judge's office appointment and service conditions are essential for the autonomy of the Supreme Court.
• Executive interference in these matters would undermine judicial independence.

2. High Court Employees Association v. State of West Bengal

The Court dealt with the role of the Governor in approving the financial rules. It clarified:

• The approval of the Governor is not intended to interfere with the Court's autonomy but to ensure fiscal discipline.
• The Chief Judge preserves the discretion in non-financial matters and protects the department of powers.

3. All India Judges Association v. Union of India

This case held the importance of accounting for the expenditure of the High Court by the Consolidated Fund, laid down the points:

• This Article ensures the financial stability of the judiciary.
• Any attempt to restrict or delay in maintaining expenses of the High Court from these funds would violate the constitutional mandate.

Comparative Analysis: High Courts and Supreme Court

Article 229 of Indian Constitution mirrors certain provisions for the Supreme Court under Article 146, highlighting a consistent approach to judicial independence at both levels. Key similarities and differences include:

Aspect	High Court (Article 229)	Supreme Court (Article 146)
Appointment Power	Chief Justice of High Court	Chief Justice of India
Governor’s Role	Approval required for financial rules	No equivalent role for the President
Financial Autonomy	Consolidated Fund of the State	Consolidated Fund of India

Conclusion

Article 229 of Indian Constitution emphasizes the independence of the state judiciary High Court's proper function, which is responsible for maintaining the financial issues and administration properly by the Chief Justice of the High Court or any other Judge; responsibility can be shifted to any other judge of High Court. This Article strengthens the foundations of judicial autonomy by emphasizing the main Judge and additional judge appointment with an administrative body and ensuring financial stability through the consolidated Fund.

However, the role of the Governor and consultation with the State Public Service Commission introduces inspections that must be performed to prevent interference with judicial independence. As the Indian judicial system is constantly evolving, regular reviews and reforms of provisions such as Article 229 will be essential.

Download Key takeaways on Article 229 of Indian Constitution PDF