Genocide Convention: Background, Laws, Genocide Committee, and Case Studies!

The Genocide Convention is a United Nations treaty. It aims to prevent and punish the crime of genocide. The Convention was adopted in 1948. It came into force in 1951. The Convention defines genocide as intentional acts of destruction. The acts are aimed at a national, ethnic, racial, or religious group. The Genocide Committee is responsible for monitoring the implementation of the treaty. The monitoring is done by the signatories of the treaty. Some notable cases of genocide are the Holocaust, the Rwandan Genocide, etc. The laws of the Genocide Convention have been used in international criminal courts. The courts prosecute individuals for their involvement in committing or ordering acts of genocide.

Genocide Convention is one of the most important topics for the UPSC IAS exam. It covers a significant part of International relations (Important International Institutions) in the General Studies Paper 2 syllabus and current events in UPSC prelims.

In this article, we shall see an overview of the Background, Laws, Genocide Committee, Case Studies of the Genocide Convention, International Court of Justice, and other facts for the UPSC exams.

What is Genocide?

The term "genocide" was coined by Raphael Lemkin. He was a Polish-Jewish lawyer. The word described the systematic murder policies. These were used by Nazis during the Holocaust. Their goal was to exterminate European Jews.

• The word "genocide" has a Greek and Latin origins.
  • The Greek word is "geno-" meaning race or tribe.
  • The Latin word is "-cide," meaning killing.
• Genocide is deliberate and systematic destruction.
  • Its goal is to wipe out a particular group completely or partially.
  • The group can be selected based on ethnicity, race, religion, or nationality.
  • The purpose is to erase the group's identity and culture.
• Genocide can manifest in various ways.
  • Examples include mass killings and forced displacement.
  • Rape and sexual violence are also common tactics.
  • Forced sterilization is another method used.
• It is universally recognized as a grave crime against humanity.
• The United Nations defined and criminalized genocide in 1948.
• This was done in the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide.

Read about United Nations Convention Against Torture from here!

What is Genocide Convention?

The Genocide Convention codified genocide as a crime in international law for the first time. Its preamble acknowledges the historical sufferings and losses which were inflicted by genocide.

• The Convention emphasizes the importance of international cooperation to prevent genocide.
  • The Convention applies to situations of war and peace.
• Its provisions require state parties to take action to prevent and punish genocide.
• Article II of the Genocide Convention provides the definition of genocide.
  • Genocide is a crime that involves the intent to destroy a group.
  • The group can be national, ethnic, racial, or religious.
  • The destruction can be complete or partial.
• The definition represents a compromise among UN Member States during the drafting of the Convention.
• The Genocide Convention identifies five acts that, when committed with the intent to destroy a group, constitute genocide.
• These acts include: 
  • Killing members of the group
  • Causing serious bodily or mental harm
  • Deliberately inflicting conditions of life to bring about physical destruction.
  • Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group
  • Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group.
• The definition of genocide has two elements.
  • The first element is the physical acts.
  • The second element is the intent to commit those acts.
• The Convention serves as an important tool for preventing and punishing the crime of genocide and promoting international cooperation to end it.

Read about the Vienna Convention on Ozone protection from here!

Background of Genocide Convention

The United Nations General Assembly adopted the Convention on 9 December 1948. The Convention was the first of its kind, establishing genocide as a crime against humanity.

• The Convention symbolized the world's pledge to "never again” to permit the crime of genocide
• The Genocide Convention was a response to World War II atrocities.
• These included the Holocaust, which lacked a legal definition.
• The Convention was drafted by Raphael Lemkin.
• He was a Polish-Jewish lawyer who had coined the term "genocide."
• He introduced it in his book Axis Rule in Occupied Europe in 1944.
• Lemkin used the term to describe Nazi policies and the Armenian genocide.
• The Genocide Convention became effective on 12 January 1951.
• It has 152 state parties as of today.
• The Convention was a critical milestone in international human rights. Also, in criminal law development.
• Its definition of genocide has been widely accepted.
• The definition has been used at national and international levels.
• This is included in the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court.

Check out the Global Environment facility from here!

Genocide Law in India

India ratified the Genocide Convention more than 50 years ago. India voluntarily ratified the Genocide Convention in 1959.

• The Convention criminalizes genocide and obligates states to enforce its prohibition. However, India has not defined genocide by law.
• India has a constitutional obligation to uphold the law and treaty obligations.
  • Article 51 of the Constitution states this obligation.
  • Article 253 of the Constitution requires Parliament to enact laws necessary to implement treaties.
• Legislation should follow the ratification of a treaty.
• This helps ensure timely implementation within the State.
• India has both international and constitutional obligations to implement the Genocide Convention.
• India's failure to define genocide may hinder compliance with the Convention
• India's lack of action to define genocide is concerning.
• India has a history of communal violence and ethnic conflict.
• Failing to define genocide may hinder India's ability to prevent and punish the crime.
• India's constitutional and treaty obligations require it to define genocide by law.
• India's inaction disregards its obligations under international law. It would ensure justice for victims of the crime.
• It would also help prevent future occurrences of genocide.

Read about United Nations Convention on Biological Diversity (UNCBD)-UPSC Notes from here!

Case Studies on Genocide

Let’s discuss few case studies associated with Genocide in detail.

Russia-Ukraine Conflict

The crisis between Russia and Ukraine is ongoing. The conflict erupted when Russia invaded Ukraine. Russia claimed it was protecting the Russian-speaking population. Ukraine accused Russia of misusing the term "genocide." Ukraine claimed Russia's actions were illegal. The impact of the conflict has been devastating for the region.

• The International Court of Justice intervened in the conflict.
  • The ICJ issued an interim order.
  • The order demanded Russia to withdraw its military operation.
  • The ICJ emphasized the severity of the conflict.
  • The order stressed the need to resolve the matter peacefully.
  • The ICJ's intervention aimed to de-escalate the conflict.
• The conflict is an example of ethnocentric clashes.
  • The situation is complex due to accusations of genocide.
  • Military force has been used to settle disputes.
  • The conflict has resulted in the loss of countless lives.
  • People have been displaced due to the conflict.
  • Infrastructure has been destroyed as a result of the conflict.
• Both parties need to engage in dialogue.
  • A peaceful resolution to the conflict is crucial.
  • The international community must support efforts to resolve the crisis.
  • Further escalation of the conflict must be prevented.
  • Diplomatic efforts are necessary to resolve the crisis.
  • The situation requires a collaborative and constructive approach.

Myanmar (Rohingya Crisis)

Myanmar has a long history of conflict between the government and ethnic minorities. The Rohingya people are a Muslim minority group in the Rakhine state. The Rohingya people have been subjected to an ongoing genocide. The conflict has resulted in the displacement of the Rohingya people.

• The conflict began in the late 1970s.
  • The Burmese government stripped the Rohingya people of their citizenship.
  • The Rohingya were rendered stateless as a result.
  • The Rohingya have experienced hatred and violence.
  • The military and Buddhist extremists have persecuted the Rohingya.
• The conflict reached its peak in 2017.
  • The Rohingya were subjected to a brutal crackdown by the military.
  • The crackdown led to a mass exodus of Rohingya people.
  • Rohingya refugees fled to neighboring Bangladesh.
  • Reports of rape, murder, and other atrocities were committed by the military.
• The situation has been called - a 'textbook example of ethnic cleansing' by the United Nations.
  • Many countries and international organizations have condemned Myanmar's government.
• In 2019, The Gambia submitted an application in the International Court of Justice.
  • The application accused Myanmar of committing mass murder, rape, and destruction of communities.
  • The accusations were against the Rohingya group in Rakhine state since 2016.
  • The ICJ's intervention aims to address human rights violations and seek justice for the Rohingya people.
  • The Gambia also requested provisional measures of protection.
  • The ICJ granted the provisional measures in January 2020.
  • The measures ordered Myanmar to prevent genocidal acts against Rohingya Muslims.

Read about the non-proliferation treaty by clicking the link!

Rwanda

The Rwandan genocide occurred between April and May of 1994. A UN tribunal, the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda (ICTR), heard the cases which were related to the Rwandan Genocide.

• The ICTR was established in 1994.
• The Court was established to prosecute individuals responsible for the Rwandan genocide.
• The genocide resulted in the deaths of hundreds of thousands of people.
• The ICTR's mandate was to ensure justice for the victims of the genocide.

• The genocide in Rwanda resulted in the deaths of at least 800,000 people.
  • The genocide occurred over a period of 100 days.
  • The ICTR has convicted 57 individuals for their role in the genocide.
  • The ICTR has acquitted 8 individuals.
  • Ten individuals are still on trial for their alleged involvement in the genocide.
• The first conviction for genocide, as defined by the 1948 Convention, was that of Jean-Paul Akayesu in 1998.
  • Jean-Paul Akayesu( mayor of Taba, Rwanda) was convicted by the ICTR.
  • Akayesu was found accountable for crimes against humanity and genocide.
  • Jean Kambanda was the interim prime minister during the genocide.

Sudan

In 2003, a rebellion broke out in Darfur, Sudan. The rebellion resulted in the mobilization of janjaweed militias by the government. The government used the militias to attack civilians in the region. The violence was widespread and resulted in the displacement of millions of people. The US Congress, Secretary of State, and President George W. Bush labeled the violence as genocide.

• The United Nations commission investigating the situation declined to declare the violence in Darfur as genocide.
  • The commission referred the matter to the International Criminal Court (ICC).
  • Omar Bashir, the president of Sudan, is now wanted by the ICC.
  • The warrants were issued on several charges, including genocide.
  • Bashir was the first head of State to be charged while in office by the ICC.
  • The warrants for Bashir's arrest remain in effect, although he has not been arrested and continues to deny the charges against him.
• South Sudan became independent in 2011.
  • Tensions and fighting continued in border regions such as Abeyi and South Kordofan.
  • The government allegedly employed similar tactics against civilians in these regions.
  • The tactics included violence, displacement, and human rights violations.
  • The situation has resulted in significant humanitarian crises in the region.
• The conflict in Sudan has been ongoing for decades.
  • Various groups have been vying for autonomy from Khartoum-based control.
  • The situation in Darfur has received international attention.
  • However, the conflict in Sudan as a whole remains complex and fraught with violence.
  • All over the nation, there have been reports of human rights violations.
  • The situation requires a concerted and collaborative approach to address the crisis and seek justice for the victims.

Read about the International Solar Alliance from here!

International Court of Justice

The primary court system of the United Nations is the International Court of Justice (ICJ). It settles legal disputes submitted by States according to international law. The ICJ provides advisory opinions on legal questions. The questions come from authorized UN bodies and specialized agencies.

• The Court was established in 1945 by the UN Charter, replacing the Permanent Court of International Justice.
  • The Court is composed of 15 judges elected to nine-year terms of office.
    • Judges are required to represent the world's major civilizations and legal systems.
    • Judges cannot be citizens of the same State.
  • To maintain continuity, the Court elects one-third of its members every three years.
  • Judges are eligible for re-election.
• The Court's seat is at the Peace Palace in The Hague, Netherlands.
  • Its official languages are English and French.
• All 193 member states of the UN are automatically parties to the Court.
  • Non-member states may become parties through the Article 93 procedure.
• If a State agrees to participate in a proceeding before the ICJ, it is obligated to comply with the Court's decision.
  • The Court's decisions are final and binding.
  • The UN Security Council may enforce them as per the UN Charter.
    • However, the permanent members of the Security Council may veto any such ruling.
• The ICJ promotes international justice. The ICJ resolves disputes between countries. The disputes are resolved in accordance with international law.
  • The ICJ's impartial and independent judgments contribute to maintaining international peace and security.
  • The ICJ's role in providing advisory opinions on legal questions is essential.
  • The advisory opinions are a tool for the UN in promoting and protecting human rights.
  • The advisory opinions also protect fundamental freedoms worldwide.

Read about ASEAN from here!

Way Forward

The Genocide Convention is an essential legal instrument. It is crucial in the fight against genocide. However, preventing and addressing genocide remains a challenge. Ongoing conflicts in various parts of the world demonstrate this. Countries such as Myanmar, Syria, and Yemen are few examples. The international community must continue to work towards preventing genocide.

Here are some ways for the effective implementation of the Genocide Convention:

• The international community should continue to act:
  • To strengthen the legal framework for preventing genocide.
  • To make offenders answerable for their deeds.
• Raising awareness about genocide is crucial
  • Educating people about its causes and consequences is vital.
  • This helps prevent its occurrence
  • Governments, civil society organizations, and the media should work together.
  • To increase public awareness about genocide
  • The importance of preventing it cannot be overstated.
• Holding perpetrators of genocide accountable is essential
  • It ensures justice for the victims.
  • And prevents future acts of genocide.
  • Accountability is crucial.
  • The international community must continue to support institutions.
  • Such as the International Criminal Court must hold the perpetrators accountable for their actions.
• Victims and survivors of genocide require significant support
  • The victims need help to recover from the trauma which they have experienced.
  • The support may include medical and psychosocial assistance.
• Addressing the root causes of genocide is crucial
  • These include intolerance, discrimination, and inequality.
  • Governments and civil society organizations should work together.
  • To promote tolerance, diversity, and human rights.
  • Social, economic, and political factors should be addressed.
  • It is essential to prevent genocide from occurring.

Conclusion

The Genocide Convention is an important legal tool. It serves to prevent and punish the crime of genocide. The Genocide Committee is associated with the Convention. The Committee continues to monitor and prosecute instances of genocide worldwide. The Convention's definition of genocide is a critical guide. It helps to identify those responsible for committing heinous crimes. The Convention also holds them accountable for their actions. Acts of genocide remain a focal point of the Convention.

Testbook provides comprehensive notes for different competitive examinations. It has always assured the quality of its product, like content pages, live tests, GK and current affairs, mocks, and so on. Ace your preparation with the Testbook App! Register for UPSC Online Classes at an affordable price through the UPSC CSE Coaching platform to boost your IAS preparation.