Look at the following statement and find out the right conclusion.
The teacher scolded Aruna in front of her classmates during project submission.
Conclusion I: The Aruna was not as popular as her other classmates.
Conclusion II: The teacher does not like Aruna.

Question

Question

This question was previously asked in

KGMU Nursing Officer 2023 Memory-Based Previous Year Paper

Answer 1

Correct Answer: Both conclusions I and II are wrong

Rationale:

The given statement is: "The teacher scolded Aruna in front of her classmates during project submission." This provides a factual description of an event but does not provide sufficient evidence to draw the conclusions mentioned.
Conclusion I states: "Aruna was not as popular as her other classmates." However, there is no mention in the statement about Aruna's popularity or her relationship with her classmates. Popularity cannot be inferred from the teacher's actions alone.
Conclusion II states: "The teacher does not like Aruna." The statement does not provide any evidence about the teacher's personal feelings toward Aruna. The teacher's act of scolding Aruna could be related to her behavior or the situation at hand, not necessarily a reflection of personal dislike.
Therefore, both conclusions are speculative and not supported by the information provided in the statement.

Explanation of Other Options:

Only conclusion I is right

Rationale: This option is incorrect because the statement does not provide any details about Aruna's popularity. The teacher's scolding cannot be directly linked to her social status or acceptance among her classmates. Thus, conclusion I cannot be considered valid.

Only conclusion II is right

Rationale: This option is incorrect because the statement does not indicate the teacher's personal feelings toward Aruna. Scolding someone does not necessarily imply dislike; it could be a disciplinary action or related to the project submission.

Both conclusions I and II are right

Rationale: This option is incorrect because neither conclusion is supported by the given statement. There is no evidence in the statement to validate either Aruna's popularity (conclusion I) or the teacher's personal feelings (conclusion II).

Conclusion

The correct answer is that both conclusions I and II are wrong. The statement provides a factual event but does not contain sufficient information to infer either Aruna's popularity or the teacher's personal feelings toward her.
When evaluating conclusions, it is important to rely only on the evidence provided in the statement and avoid making assumptions or interpretations that go beyond the given information.